Related Articles
JERUSALEM – The British chief prosecutor Karim Khan for the International Criminal Court(ICC) published an academic essay in 2013 that suggested his own current effort to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu would be a travesty of justice because the court cannot provide due process to defendants.
The Washington, D.C.-based Middle East Media Research Institute (MEMRI) located Khan’s essay, which waspublished by Duke University’s Law School, and analyzed key elements of the academic paper.
Yigal Carmon, the founder and president of MEMRI, wrote that Khan’s essay, titled”Defensive Practices: Representing Clients Before the International Criminal Court,”revealed that “The ICC is incapable of delivering justice.”
Carmon cited passages from the essay that Khan co-authored with the attorney Anand A. Shah, who is listed as a member of the New York State Bar.
ICC REQUESTS ARREST WARRANTS FOR NETANYAHU, HAMAS LEADERS OVER ‘WAR CRIMES’
Karim Khan is the ICC’s chief prosecutor. (Getty Images)
Khan’s academic paper places big question marks over whether defendants, who are hauled before the world court, can secure a fair trial.
In one telling example of the cards allegedly being stacked against the defendant at the ICC, Khan wrote “[ICC procedures] allow[s] the prosecutor to submit and rely on anonymous summaries of witness evidence that may be significantly lacking in substance, coherence, or both…”
With respect to heightened publicity and media buzz, Khan argued in his essaythat the defendant faces another obstacle to a fair judicial process at the ICC.”In the case of a client suspected or accused of committing international crimes, the public perception of the client’s guilt is often further magnified by the assistance of well-financed civil-society groups, nongovernmental organizations, and international media pushing a narrative that becomes accepted as the ‘truth’ even before the client appears in court.”
Lawyers for former Liberian President Charles Taylor, from left to right, Karim Khan, an unidentified lawyer and James L. Supuwood, attend the third status conference in the case of The Prosecutor vs. Charles Ghankay Taylor at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands, on Jan. 26, 2007. (Photo by KOEN VAN WEEL/POOL/AFP via Getty Images)
Khan also noted deficiencies with the evidentiary rules at the ICC. He wrote “The applicable standard of proof at the confirmation stage – ‘sufficient evidence to establish substantial grounds to believe’ – is, of course, lower than the beyond-a-reasonable-doubt standard required to obtain a conviction at the trial stage.”
The ICC is located in The Hague, Netherlands.
Earlier this month, Khan asked the ICC to issue arrest warrants against Netanyahu and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for alleged war crimes during the Jewish state’s campaign to defeat the Hamas terrorist movement in the Gaza Strip.
BIDEN SLAMS ICC’S ‘OUTRAGEOUS’ REQUEST FOR NETANYAHU ARREST WARRANT
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, right, and Israeli Defense Minister Yoav Gallant are pictured in the West Bank in August 2023. (Amos Ben-Gershom (GPO)/Handout/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
In 2007, Khan was also on the verge of being held in contempt by the ICC during his representation of formerLiberian President Charles Taylor, who was accused of carrying out war crimes in Sierra Leone.
Thepresiding judge warned Khan at the time that “your code of conduct cannot override a court order which I made a few minutes ago,” and the court “directed Khan to sit down.” The judge “invited the prosecution to continue with its opening statement” when Khan shunned the legal proceeding. He “dramatically picked up his materials and walked out of the courtroom,” according to The Cambridge companion to International Criminal Law.The ICC convicted Taylor in 2012.
Terrorists from Hamas are seen during an anti-Israel military march in Gaza City. (Yousef Masoud/Majority World/Universal Images Group via Getty Images)
Hamas invaded Israel on Oct. 7 and massacred nearly 1,200 people, including more than 30 Americans. Hamas also kidnapped over 250 people. The jihadi terrorist organization is currently holding 125 hostages in Gaza.
Tal Heinrich, a spokeswoman for Israel’s government, told Fox News Digital that the ICC is waging a “vicious smear” campaign against Israeli leaders. She said Israel’s government has not yet read Khan’s 2013 essay or the MEMRI report.
Heinrich added that the ICC will not deter Israel from its plan to defeat the Hamas terrorist movement. Netanyahu said about the ICC arrest warrant that “this is whatthe new antisemitism looks like.”
A general view of the International Criminal Court building in The Hague, Netherlands on April 30, 2024. (Selman Aksunger/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Fox News Digital sent numerous Email press queries to Khan and the ICC. Multiple Fox News Digital telephone calls to the ICC were not returned.
Fadi El Abdallah, a spokesman for the ICC, told Fox News Digital via WhatsApp text message about the lack of response from the prosecutor’s office that “They may be busy. Thank you for your understanding.” He added in a second WhatsApp message “I[c]ant (sic) be of further assistance as it is something for the Prosecutor’s team to respond to your inquiry.” Efforts to reach Khan’s co-author,Shah, were not successful.
Benjamin Weinthal reports on Israel, Iran, Syria, Turkey and Europe. You can follow Benjamin on Twitter @BenWeinthal, and email him at benjamin.weinthal@fox.com
